Celebration & Wedding Cakes

At Newburgh Flour Shop, we strive to enhance any celebration, big or small, with the perfect cake. Choosing your celebration or wedding cake should be a fun and joyous experience—and we’d be so honored to be part of it! Start the conversation today by giving us a call at 845-568-3400 or emailing cakes@newburghflourshop.com.

For wedding cakes, please give us a call to schedule a meeting and receive a quote for your cake.

Please allow at least 72 hours (3 days) notice when ordering your custom celebration cake.

If ordering a themed or character celebration cake, please call our bakery in Newburgh at least one week prior to your event.

As Seen on The Knot
Review us on The Knot
Newburgh-Flour-Shop-22.jpg
 

BASIC CELEBRATION/BIRTHDAY CAKE YIELD AND PRICING

  • 6” Round: 8 to 10 servings, starting at $20

  • 8” Round: 12 to 16 servings, starting at $27

  • 10” Round: 18 to 22 servings, starting at $35

  • Tiered or Stacked Cakes: Additional $15

    Gold paint, color, or texture on buttercream is included in the above pricing.

    Some special features, such as gold leaf application or special character creation, require an extra charge.

    BASIC WEDDING CAKE PRICING AND INFO

  • Pricing for wedding cake packages starts at $6 per slice.

  • A $10 delivery fee will be added to the final total cost.

  • Wedding cake packages include: a 3-tier (10”, 8”, 6”) vanilla buttercream frosted cake and any additional cutting cakes to accommodate guest count.

  • Smooth or basic textured or piped finishes are included.

  • Color, gold or silver leaf or airbrush, and other more detailed designs are subject to an upcharge.

  • Cakes are delivered on a finished and sealed pine wood round. A finished wood stump is available as a base for an additional $45.

***IMPORTANT NOTE: Please make sure to call or email cakes@newburghflourshop.com and schedule a meeting with our pastry team to discuss your wedding cake vision and receive an accurate quote.***

Take a look below to check out the sponge, filling, and frosting flavors we typically have available in house.

Specific sponge, filling, and frosting flavors not offered below are available upon request!

newburghflourshopcake1.jpg

AVAILABLE FILLINGS

  • Dark Chocolate Ganache

  • Chocolate Mousse

  • Sweetened Cream Cheese

  • Seasonal Fruit Jam

  • Vanilla Buttercream

  • Chocolate Buttercream

  • Vanilla Buttercream with Sprinkles

newburghflourshopcake2.jpg

AVAILABLE BUTTERCREAM FROSTINGS

  • Chocolate

  • Vanilla

AVAILABLE SPONGE CAKES

newburgh flour shop cake slices.jpg
Name *
Name
Phone *
Phone

Let’s talk about your cake!

Shoot us an email to start the conversation about your custom celebration or wedding cake here. We’ll be sure to get back to you ASAP to start discussing your cake vision!